Table of Contents
Two landlords own identical two-bed terraces on the same street. One pays £312 a year for buildings and rent cover. The other pays £540. The second isn’t being overcharged. Their policy includes twelve months of lost rent, £5 million of public liability and accidental damage caused by tenants. The first landlord discovered the difference in March, standing in a hallway full of water while a claims handler asked how long the property had sat empty.
Buying cover well is mostly a process problem, not a shopping problem. Work through the steps below in order and you’ll finish with a policy that actually pays out, without paying for things you’ll never claim on.
Step 1: Check you’re buying the right type of policy
A standard home policy is built around owner-occupiers. Insurers ask whether the property is your main residence, and a let counts as a material change. That means a claim can be refused even when the fire had nothing to do with the tenancy.
If you’ve converted a former home into a rental, this is the most common way landlords end up uninsured without realising it. There’s a detailed look at where standard home policies leave landlords exposed if you want the specifics before you switch.
Step 2: Insure the rebuild cost, not the asking price
Buildings cover pays to reconstruct the property from the ground up: demolition, materials, labour, professional fees. It has nothing to do with what the house would sell for.
Take a three-bed semi in Stoke with a market value of £215,000. Rebuilding it might cost £165,000, because land value plays no part and modern construction is faster than most people assume. Declare £215,000 and you’ve slightly overpaid. Declare £120,000 to keep the premium down and you’ve triggered the average clause, which lets the insurer scale every payout by the proportion you underinsured. A £20,000 escape-of-water claim on a property insured at roughly 73% of its rebuild cost becomes about £14,600.
Use a rebuild cost calculator rather than a guess, and recheck it after any extension or loft conversion.
Step 3: Size lost rent cover against a realistic void
Rent cover pays the income you lose while the property is uninhabitable after an insured event. Most policies cap it one of two ways: a monthly limit, or a percentage of the buildings sum insured, often 10% to 20%.
If you collect £950 a month, a 10% cap on a £165,000 buildings sum gives you £16,500, comfortably more than a year’s rent. The same cap on a £95,000 flat gives £9,500, under ten months. Add the wait for a builder, an assessor and council sign-off and ten months can vanish on a serious fire or flood.
Step 4: Decide who insures what before the tenancy starts
Landlord policies cover the building and the things you supplied: fitted kitchens, carpets, white goods, the sofa that came with the flat. They don’t cover the tenant’s laptop, clothes or television. That split causes more arguments than any other part of a tenancy, and the dividing line is set out in who pays when something breaks in a rented property.
Write your own contents schedule instead of estimating. Walk the property room by room: beds, mattresses, wardrobes, washing machine, fridge-freezer, blinds, garden furniture. A furnished two-bed usually lands between £4,000 and £8,000 of replacement value. If a burst pipe ruins £6,000 of it and you insured £2,500, the rest comes out of your pocket.
Step 5: Read the exclusions that catch landlords out
Most of the difference between a cheap quote and a good one hides in the small print. Check these before you pay:
- Malicious damage by tenants. Some policies exclude it entirely, others include it only where there’s been a conviction. Ask which applies to you.
- Accidental damage. Usually an add-on. Worth the money if you let furnished or to students.
- Vacancy. Cover often stops after 30 or 45 consecutive days empty. Refurbishments and probate sales both break that rule.
- Wear and tear. Never covered. A fifteen-year-old boiler failing is maintenance, not a claim.
- Liability limits. £1 million sounds enormous until a tenant’s guest falls through a rotten balcony. £2 million to £5 million is normal for a small portfolio.
- The excess. £250 versus £500 shifts the premium less than most people assume. Choose the figure you could pay in a bad month.
Cutting corners here is how landlords end up with a policy that looks fine until it matters. There’s a useful breakdown of where cheap policies fall short that’s worth ten minutes before you commit.
Step 6: Compare quotes on identical terms
Put three quotes in a spreadsheet and line up the same six rows: buildings sum insured, contents sum insured, rent cover limit, liability limit, accidental damage yes or no, excess. If one quote is £180 cheaper and three of those rows are lower, it isn’t cheaper. It’s a smaller policy.
Two things reliably cut premiums without shrinking cover: a higher excess and a clean five-year claims history. Two that push it up: subsidence recorded at the address, and a flat above commercial premises. The full cost picture is covered in what landlord insurance covers and what it costs.
Step 7: Set the tenant insurance requirement properly
Asking tenants to hold their own contents cover is sensible and completely normal. Enforcing it badly isn’t. You can request proof of cover at the start of the tenancy and at renewal, and you can write the requirement into the agreement. You can’t insist on a named insurer, demand to be added as an interested party on a standard renters policy, or buy cover on their behalf and bill them without agreement. The boundaries are explained in what landlords can require of renters insurance.
Step 8: Diary the triggers that change your cover
Policies are priced on the facts you gave at inception. When those facts shift, tell the insurer, or a claim can be trimmed or rejected. Set a reminder for each of these:
- A new tenancy, especially moving from a professional couple to four sharers, which changes the rating to HMO
- Any gap of more than three weeks between tenants
- Building work, from a new kitchen to a loft conversion
- A change of letting agent or management arrangement
- Each renewal date, when the rebuild figure deserves another look
The first 48 hours after a claim
Most claim problems are created in the first two days, long before an assessor turns up.
Report the loss immediately, even if you haven’t decided whether to claim. Call the emergency helpline if water is involved, because many policies include trace-and-access cover for the leak itself, and using the approved contractor keeps the cost inside the policy rather than arguing about it later.
Photograph everything before a single item is moved or thrown out, then keep the damaged goods until the loss adjuster confirms you can dispose of them. A skip full of ruined carpet is worth nothing. A photographed, itemised skip is worth the replacement cost.
Keep receipts for emergency spending. £400 for a dehumidifier and a night in a hotel is recoverable; £400 you can’t evidence usually isn’t. And if the tenant has to move out, start the rent cover conversation on day one rather than when the builders arrive, because the clock on alternative accommodation often runs from the date the property became uninhabitable, not the date you got round to claiming.


