Table of Contents
Ask ten people why they lost money in their first two years of investing and you’ll get ten different stories. Read enough of them and a pattern appears. Almost nobody loses because they picked the wrong stock. They lose because of how they behaved around the stock they picked.
The seven mistakes below show up again and again, in brokerage data, in academic studies of retail trading, and in the emails I get from readers. None of them are exotic. Most are the kind of thing you only notice after they’ve already cost you a few hundred dollars.
1. Assuming a great company is automatically a great stock
Cisco made routers for the internet build-out in the 1990s, and it was genuinely one of the best businesses of the era. Revenue grew, margins were fat, the products were everywhere. Its stock peaked near $80 in March 2000. It did not trade above that level again until late 2021.
Twenty-one years. The company kept selling routers the whole time. Investors who bought the story at the top simply paid too much for it.
This is the mistake that hides behind every other mistake. A stock is a business wrapped in a price, and the price matters as much as the business. A company trading at 60 times earnings has to grow quickly for years just to justify today’s number. Miss that growth by a little and the multiple compresses by a lot. You can be right about the business and still lose 40% of your money.
2. Treating a $0 commission as free
Free trades are not free. You pay in the spread, in slippage on thin names, in currency conversion, and in fund fees that get deducted whether you notice them or not.
Run the fund fee math once and it stays with you. Say two index funds both earn 8% a year before costs. One charges 0.05%, the other charges 0.75%. Put $50,000 in the cheap one and after 30 years you have roughly $496,000. Put it in the expensive one and you have roughly $408,000. An $88,000 gap, created by a fee difference most people would call trivial.
Trading costs compound the same way. A round trip in a thinly traded small cap can quietly cost you 1% or more between the spread and the fill you actually get. Make twenty round trips a year and you’ve handed over a fifth of your account before the market has done anything at all.
3. Selling because the screen is red
In March 2020 the S&P 500 fell 34% in 23 trading days. It’s easy to look at that chart now and think, obviously you hold. Living through it was different. Schools closed, airports emptied, and every headline said the number would keep going up.
Plenty of people sold near the bottom and then waited for clarity. By the time they felt comfortable again, the index had rallied more than 60% off the lows. They locked in the loss and missed the recovery, which is the only combination that actually destroys long-term returns.
Panic is expensive in ways that go beyond portfolios, which is something I wrote about in how panic lost me money in a non-investment way. The lesson travels. Decisions made in the middle of a spike in heart rate are almost never the decisions you’d make on a quiet Tuesday.
4. Position sizes that can actually hurt you
New investors tend to think about whether a stock will go up. They rarely think about how much of the account is riding on the answer.
Do the arithmetic. A 5% position that triples adds 10% to your portfolio. A 40% position that halves takes 20% off it. The second scenario requires a 25% gain on everything else just to get back to even. One stock, one bad quarter, one accounting scandal, and you’ve spent two years digging out.
Most people can hold a concentrated position safely when they have a salary coming in every month and can keep adding. That cushion disappears if you’re living off the portfolio, a point made well in a FIRE investor with no paycheck cannot afford to be too wrong. Your position sizing should reflect the size of your safety net, not your conviction level.
5. Buying without writing anything down
Before you click buy, answer four questions in a note on your phone:
- Why am I buying this, in one sentence a stranger could understand?
- What would prove me wrong? Be specific, not “if it drops.”
- How long am I willing to wait before the thesis plays out?
- What percentage of my portfolio is this, and why that number?
It takes four minutes. It also removes about 80% of the impulse buys you’d otherwise make, because half of them fall apart the moment you try to write the first sentence.
The real value shows up later. When the stock drops 25%, you can reread your reasoning and decide whether the thesis broke or the price just got cheaper. Without that note you’re guessing, and guessing under pressure is how small losses become permanent ones.
6. Chasing whatever already went up
ARK Innovation returned about 153% in 2020. Money poured in after that number was printed, because that’s when it became visible. The fund then fell 23% in 2021 and 67% in 2022. The investors who arrived in early 2021 experienced the collapse and none of the run-up.
This is recency bias dressed up as research. A three-year chart is a terrible reason to buy something, because the entire chart is already priced in. If you want to buy into a theme, buy it with a thesis that would survive a 50% drawdown, which is roughly the argument in it feels like 1999 again: how to profit from the boom responsibly.
The alternative isn’t to avoid growth entirely. It’s to start from the fundamentals rather than the ticker’s recent performance. If you want a worked example of what that looks like, this breakdown of the top 7 stocks to invest in 2026 for long-term growth walks through the reasoning rather than just the returns.
7. Confusing volatility with risk, then checking the app twice a day
Risk is the chance of permanent loss. Volatility is the price moving around on the way to wherever it ends up. They feel identical on a bad afternoon, which is why so many people treat a red day as evidence that something is broken.
The daily check makes this worse. Historically the S&P 500 closes lower than the previous day about 46% of the time. Check every morning and you’ve scheduled a mild disappointment for nearly half your life. Check once a quarter and the odds flip dramatically in your favour, because quarterly returns are positive roughly two-thirds of the time.
Widen the lens further and the picture improves again. Over rolling 20-year periods, US large-cap returns have been positive in essentially every window on record. Nothing about that changes because of one bad earnings season in a stock you own.
So set a schedule and stick to it. Open the app on the first weekend of each quarter. Rebalance once a year, or when a position drifts more than five percentage points from your target. Read about the year ahead in something like this investment outlook for public and private stocks in 2026 instead of refreshing a price. Spend the time you save on your income, your skills, or your sleep.
That’s the unglamorous truth behind all seven of these. The returns usually come from doing less, better, for longer, and from refusing to make decisions at the exact moments your body most wants you to make one.


