Table of Contents
There are about forty tubs on the shelf of my local supplement shop and maybe six of them are worth the money. The rest cost more per gram of protein than a chicken breast, hide behind phrases like “proprietary blend”, or taste like the inside of a vitamin jar. None of that helps when you’re standing there for the first time with no idea what you’re looking at.
This is a from-scratch guide. No brand recommendations, no shortcuts. Just what the stuff is, the types you’ll actually find, how much you need, and how to read a label well enough to avoid paying £45 for flavoured sugar.
What Protein Powder Actually Is
Strip it back and protein powder is food that has been dried and ground fine. Whey is the watery liquid left after milk is turned into cheese. It gets filtered, pasteurised and spray-dried into the powder in the tub. Pea protein comes from yellow split peas. Rice, soy, egg and hemp follow much the same process. No alchemy involved, just concentrated protein with most of the water removed.
The reason it exists is convenience, followed by cost per gram. Getting 30g of protein at 7am means cooking chicken or eating five eggs. A scoop takes twenty seconds.
For scale:
- 100g cooked chicken breast: about 31g protein
- One scoop of whey: about 24g protein, roughly 110 calories
- Three large eggs: 19g protein
- 200g Greek yoghurt: about 20g protein
Nothing on that list beats the others. The powder is simply the one you can carry in a bag.
The Three Types You’ll Actually See
Shops stock dozens of varieties, but almost every tub is one of these three families.
Whey concentrate and whey isolate
Whey is the default for good reason: it’s cheap, it mixes, and it’s rich in leucine, the amino acid that switches on muscle protein synthesis. Concentrate is roughly 70-80% protein by weight, with a few grams of carbs and fat per scoop and a little lactose. Isolate is filtered harder, lands at 90% protein or above, and suits people who get bloated from dairy. It usually costs 20-40% more per tub, which is only worth it if lactose is genuinely a problem for you.
Casein
Casein is the other milk protein and it digests slowly, which is why it turns into a thick paste in a shaker. That slow release makes it popular before bed. It isn’t essential, and most people do fine with whey, but it’s useful if you train late and want something that keeps you full overnight.
Plant blends
Pea protein on its own is low in methionine. Rice protein is low in lysine. Blended together they cover each other’s gaps and land close to whey on amino acid profile. Soy is complete by itself. Plant powders used to be gritty and tasted of cardboard; the better ones now mix almost as well as dairy, though they generally cost more per gram. There’s a fuller whey, casein and plant blends compared breakdown if you want the detail side by side.
How Much Protein You Actually Need
Research keeps landing on 1.6-2.2g of protein per kilogram of bodyweight per day for building muscle, or roughly 0.7-1g per pound. An 80kg person is looking at 128-176g a day. Spread over four meals, that’s 32-44g at each sitting, which is about the dose that maximally stimulates muscle protein synthesis in one go.
Most people eating a normal mixed diet get somewhere between 60 and 90g. That leaves a shortfall of 50-80g, and that shortfall is the entire reason protein powder exists as a product. One or two scoops closes it. Four scoops don’t make you grow four times as fast.
Reading a Label Without Getting Fooled
Serving size is where beginners get caught. One brand’s scoop is 25g and delivers 20g of protein. Another’s is 40g and delivers 24g. The second looks better until you work out you’re paying for 16g of filler per scoop.
Three numbers do most of the work:
- Protein per 100g of powder. Anything under 70g deserves suspicion unless it’s a flavoured blend you specifically want.
- Cost per 25g of protein. Divide the tub price by the number of servings, then by the protein per serving. Under £0.70 is solid for isolate; under £0.50 is excellent.
- The ingredient list. If glycine, taurine or creatine sit high up, the protein figure may be inflated by amino spiking, where cheap free amino acids bump the nitrogen reading without adding complete protein.
There are more traps than that, and most are avoidable with five minutes of label reading. This piece on nine buying mistakes that cost you money and muscle covers the ones that catch people most often.
Beginner Mistakes Worth Skipping
- Buying a 2kg tub of a flavour you’ve never tasted. Two kilos of cookies-and-cream you hate is a £60 mistake.
- Picking the cheapest tub per kilo without checking protein per 100g. You’re often buying maltodextrin with a scoop of protein in it.
- Believing a shake must be drunk within 30 minutes of training. The window runs for hours, and the daily total matters far more.
- Replacing meals with shakes. Powder fills gaps; it isn’t a diet.
- Ignoring lactose intolerance. Bloating and cramps after a shake usually point to concentrate, not to protein in general.
- Buying a mass gainer for the calories. Many are 60-70% maltodextrin, which is cheap carbohydrate sold at protein prices.
How to Actually Use It
Keep it simple. One scoop in 250-300ml of water or milk, shaken hard for fifteen seconds, is the baseline. Water keeps calories low and the flavour sharper; milk adds 8g of protein and a creamier texture for about 120 extra calories. A frozen banana and a spoon of cocoa blended in turns it into something you’ll look forward to.
It works outside the shaker too. Stirred into porridge, mixed through yoghurt, baked into pancakes. A scoop added to a bowl of oats turns a 12g breakfast into a 35g one.
Timing matters less than the internet suggests. Hitting your daily total with one shake at breakfast and one after training does the job. If you train fasted at 6am, a shake afterwards is convenient rather than magic.
Picking Your First Tub in Four Steps
First, choose dairy or plant based on how you digest them, not on marketing. Second, set a cost ceiling per 25g of protein and stick to it. Third, buy the smallest tub available in a plain flavour, chocolate or vanilla, so you can add your own extras later. Fourth, use it daily for three weeks and note taste, mixing and digestion. Then scale up.
If you’d rather see that process with actual prices and worked calculations, the six-step walkthrough with real numbers runs through it properly.
Start With One Tub and Give It a Month
The honest answer to which protein powder is best is that it depends on three things nobody else can measure for you: how your stomach handles dairy, what you can afford each month, and whether you’ll actually drink the stuff. A £70 isolate that gives you cramps is worse than a £30 concentrate that doesn’t.
So buy small, use it consistently, and judge it on the only things that matter. Grams of protein per pound spent. How you feel an hour later. Whether the tub is empty in six weeks. If it is, buy it again. If it’s still three-quarters full in March, you’ve learned something more useful than any review could tell you. Once you know your own preferences, choosing without the hype becomes a lot easier.


